Anonymous

Twilight or Harry Potter?

8

8 Answers

Lee Ae Tae Profile
Lee Ae Tae answered

Harry Potter for sure.  There are so many god meanings and important lessons that are taught in Harry Potter, such as humanity, loyalty, and friendship, and Twilight is about a girl who falls in love with a glittering vampire and gets pregnant. 

Aldrich Ames Profile
Aldrich Ames answered

Harry Potter is way better than twilight. I'm not a fan of Harry potter much but Harry potter and the books have much more meaning and lessons than twilight and is IMO better.

Tris Fray Potter Profile

HARRY POTTER!!!!  Twilight is full of sparkling vampires, 50 reasons to have a boyfriend, hot guys, and has so much more depth to the characters.  Not only that, but in Harry Potter, the bad guys are bad guys for a reason, and nothing's not always as it seemed to be.  Harry Potter seems real, it seems to come to life, and there have been times that, although I don't believe in magic, I question if Harry Potter has been made up.  Twilight was just one of those books that was popular for a year or two and then everyone forgot about it.  It's been almost twenty years since the first book came out and it's gaining populatity with the Harry Potter and the Cursed Child play, Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them movie, JK Rowling, Bonnie Wright and Evanna Lynch's work with Lumos and Emma Watson's work with the He for She foundation.  Stephanie Meyer only took part in a fundraiser, nothing compared to Lumos, which needs dedication to run properly.

I'm going to stop here because I could go on forever why Harry Potter is better than Twilight, and I would, but I have stuff to do.

Levi F. Profile
Levi F. answered

I've never read Twilight or seen the movies, so I can't comment fairly, but Harry Potter seems to me to be much more interesting. I've read all the books and seen the movies multiple times and I love that story. As lofty as the literature I read now is, I'll never stop liking Harry Potter.

Pepper pot Profile
Pepper pot answered

Harry Potter by far. I've read the books,  I haven't seen all the Harry Potter Movies though.

Twilight came across as a stroppy teenager with no sense who doted on a vampire.  A vampire who's skin was ice cold and like marble, doesn't sound like cuddling up material to me.

He was born in 1901, so even though as a vampire he may have looked 17, he was in fact 107 years old, which would look like this if he'd been human...

And she's 17!

This creepiness was pushed home when you saw the amount of graduation hats Edward had on the wall.

It is a 12 rated movie and has scenes of vampires killing humans, and a human marrying and getting pregnant by a vampire. She then has to drink human blood to feed the fetus, and then her vampire partner tears it out of her with his teeth when she goes into labour. Whilst lying there with body broken and her insides torn out, he proceeds too bite her and turn her into a vampire, who said romance was dead? Pardon the pun!

How is this something you'd want your 12 year old to aspire to? It is disturbing and grotesque.  I certainly wouldn't let my niece and nephews read or watch it.

Answer Question

Anonymous